
| |
The differences between X-Ray radiation therapy and proton
therapy are many. In the perfect doses, X-Ray radiation therapy will help
check many cancers. But sometimes, inefficient physicians may not be able
to adequately judge the radiation dosages and the centers where they are
required, thus leading to damage to healthy cells.
This is checked by
a less effective but healthier less-than-required dose which does not
harm healthy cells and also prevents many side-effects. This effect can
be checked by proton therapy. Even at much higher dosages, it does not
harm healthy cells or vital organs and at the same time controls cancer.
Thus, protons are basically far superior as a therapy to X-Ray radiation.
All tissues comprise molecules which in turn consist of cells. Each cell
has a central nucleus. Negatively charged particles called electrons orbit
around the nucleus.
When charges particles with energy pass near the negative charge of electrons,
due to their charge, they attract electrons out of their orbits, as is
the case with protons. Known as ionization, it drastically affects both
the characteristics and structures of the atoms and the molecules. This
is very beneficial and forms the base of radiation therapy. Ionization
leads to cancer cell damage, especially the involved genes and DNA strands.
This leads to loss of cellular functions such as binary division or ability
to reproduce. These cells are attacked by an enzyme which tries to repair
the cell, and might even succeed, so hence a high dosage is require which
can damage the cell beyond enzyme repair. Since a cancer cell is mutated
cell, it has far lesser repair capability as compared to a healthy cell.
Thus, they undergo permanent transformation and this leads to large cases
of cancer cell death. Hence, bad cells can be selectively destroyed among
good cells.
Generic X-Ray radiation therapy and proton therapy both work on the principle
of selective cell destruction. In proton therapy however, energy distribution
of protons is much more targeted and can effectively and efficiently be
directed directly to the tissue volumes identified by physicians as target
zones. This leads consequently to more control over the treatment and
also a far more efficient form of therapy.
In radiation therapy, on the
other hand, a careful dosage must be designed so as to only cause damage
to selective cells, and even that damage should be sufficient to cause
permanent breakdown. X-Ray beams have no charge or mass. This leads to
energy deposition both beyond and before the actual cancer hotzone. This
has an unnecessary damaging effect on healthy tissues and bones, which
could disrupt the regimen.
Protons are specific velocity energized, which directly determines the
distance they penetrate. This is because as they go through the body,
they slow down, and increasingly react with orbiting electrons.
As protons get to their targeted zones, they are designed to have maximum
interaction. Thus, they have the most energizing effect in cancer zones
only. Surrounding healthy cells receive much less injury as compared to
standard radiation therapy.
This dose-distribution characteristic allows an oncologist to increase
the dosage significantly while causing minimal damage to healthy surrounding
cells, due to also subsequently decreasing the dosage they receive. This
allows a lot more radiation dosage than would otherwise be given during
radiation therapy. This leads to fewer side-effects, more impact on tumor
sites and also greater tumor control.
The best part is that nothing is felt by the patients during treatment.
Less normal-tissue injury results in far fewer side effects such as vomiting,
nausea and diarrhea. This is directly proportional to a better life quality
after treatment.